Intelligent locker compartments can be door-based or drawer-based. Both are effective ways to store equipment, but each suits different business needs.
Door compartments are individually stackable units. They are usually stacked vertically to maximize wall space. They can come in various sizes, but the size is fixed, typically allowing you to track only one item or kit per compartment.
Drawer systems have a horizontal pull-out tray, usually only installed at lower heights for accessibility. They offer high-density asset storage. You use cut foam inserts, dividers, or even internal compartment doors to hold different items. ecos drawer-based systems are actually equipped with automated motorized closing mechanisms, the only system on the market with this feature.
|
Feature |
Doors |
Drawers |
|
Physical Layout |
Individual compartments stack vertically to maximize wall space. |
Flat, horizontal pull-out mechanism. More space-efficient, 2x storage space |
|
Asset Capacity |
Fixed compartment sizes. |
Flexible internal layout accommodating variable item capacity. |
|
Closing Mechanism |
Closed by hand. RFID asset tracking is compromised if the door is left open. |
Motorized drawers close automatically (Feature unique to ecos lockers). |
|
Security & Material |
Solid steel doors are common. Clear doors allow quick visual inspection but typically require thinner, less secure materials. Potential security threat as critical assets are visible to everyone. |
Secure steel plates on the front. Instead of visual inspection, LED status indicators on the door show device presence and charge status. |
|
Space Efficiency |
Good for maximizing use of wall space. |
High-density. Takes roughly half the space of comparable door systems. |
|
Remote Management |
Standard access controls, user management, and asset tracking. |
Fully accessible to centralized Security Operation Centers (SOCs), allowing for remote opening and closing. |
|
Ideal Use Cases |
Large, bulky items (e.g., Pelican kit cases) or equipment that must remain vertical (e.g., radios in charger racks). |
Storing critical assets that need strict security controls when little floor space is available. |
The choice between a door-based and a drawer-based smart locker system largely depends on the mix of equipment you’re storing and the workflows it supports.
Many modern smart lockers support RFID equipment tracking. Scanners attached to the locker system read RFID tags on or embedded in stored devices to verify when they’re taken or returned, adding an extra layer of intelligence. Scanners are often attached to the access control terminal on the outside, but advanced locker systems embed them directly in the compartments or drawers so the system can automatically read equipment IDs during transactions. That eliminates the possibility of someone forgetting to scan the device when they sign it back in.
RFID tracking is also only useful if users remember to close the door. If they leave the lockers unsecured, your verified chain of custody instantly breaks. Motorized drawers resolve this issue by closing automatically after a set period.
There’s another option, too. Instead of relying solely on wireless tags, drawer-based smart lockers can include precision scales that sense weight down to the gram (⅓ oz). They calculate exactly when and how much inventory is removed and provide highly accurate usage data without requiring the user to scan an item. ecos’ door-based lockers can also include scales.
For example, you log a new radio weighing 52g into storage. Then, whenever that drawer records a weight change of 52g, the system records a confirmed sign-out or return of that specific radio.
Both door and drawer-based smart lockers have remote management dashboards that allow administrators to manage users and the properties of stored equipment. For example, they can change which user groups can sign out radios, give unlimited access to senior technicians, and limit a front-line service team to 4-hour signouts. These dashboards are typically accessible remotely through a secure web portal.
Beyond basic management, because they’re motorized, drawer systems are fully accessible to centralized Security Operations Centers (SOCs), which can remotely lock and unlock drawers for emergencies and approved exceptions or quickly change user permissions for temporary access needs.
Ideal for: Insured assets, high-value electronics, and devices with sensitive data.
When you manage high-value or sensitive assets, security drives many of your business decisions. Drawer systems provide the most secure, automated storage and peace of mind. When an employee retrieves or returns an asset, the drawer automatically shuts and locks. This removes human error from the equation, ensuring critical items aren’t left exposed if a worker accidentally forgets to close a door.
Ideal for: Bulky equipment, heavy tools, and dock-charged devices.
Traditional door-based compartments remain the standard for storing larger or bulkier tools. Lifting heavy equipment straight out of a front-facing compartment is often more ergonomic than pulling it up from a deep drawer. Additionally, devices that sit directly in stationary charging docks, such as two-way radios, generally require the vertical clearance standard locker doors provide.
Many organizations mistakenly believe they must choose one form factor for their entire facility, leading to compromises in either space or security. The good news is you don’t necessarily need to take an all-or-nothing approach. Smart locker systems on the market can integrate both door and drawer storage to match your specific asset profiles.
This hybrid approach often involves deploying a large bank of motorized drawers for most managed assets and integrating a small, dedicated bank of traditional doored compartments for bulky kits.
Choosing the right locker configuration boils down to matching your daily workflows to the locker hardware using three criteria. Use this simple, three-stage framework to evaluate your facility's requirements before selecting a smart locker system:
Reach out to our team to talk through options for your use case.